Call to action REMINDER: Working group on DSI
This is just a reminder about the new working group (WG) to raise awareness on obligations to respect access and benefit-sharing rights under the Convention on Biodiversity, the FAO Treaty on Plant Genetic Resources, and the Nagoya Protocols on Access and Benefit Sharing.
The WG will encourage scientists to learn about the obligations applicable in their country, organizations, or work topic and contribute to effective policies. Plant scientists need to know about and have a voice on this.As you know, Ros Gleadow, Brad Sherman, and Robert Henry have already published a blog post on our blog on this matter (below these lines).
Please consider again sharing this invitation with your contacts. The first WG meeting will take place at some point on the 22-26 February week. Thank you to those who have already contacted us.
Don’t hesitate to contact me if you are interested in joining or if you have any questions.
Stay safe everyone.
Chief Communications Officer
Global Plant Council
Authors: Ros Gleadow, Brad Sherman and Robert HenryMany plant scientists rely on open access to information such as DNA sequence data to do their work. They are probably also aware of obligations to respect access and benefit sharing (ABS) rights under the Convention on Biodiversity (CBD) and the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) Treaty on Plant Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture (The Treaty) and maybe the Nagoya Protocols on Access and Benefit Sharing. These arrangements have long been understood to cover the actual biological material (the plant) but international moves to extend these agreements to include associated data such as digital DNA sequence information (DSI) may impact more directly on the activities of plant scientists (Marden, 2018).
Reconciling the importance of ongoing open access to sequence data that many see as critical to advancing science and protection of the legitimate rights of countries and traditional owners of biological resources is challenging. The issues are complex and vary depending upon the laws in each country, when and where plants are sourced and the particular plant species. Historical collections, such as those in seed banks or gene banks, may be especially difficult to use as it may be impossible to satisfy the needs for prior informed consent for material collected a long time ago (Sherman and Henry, 2020).
Particularities of digital DNA sequence information (DSI)
Sequence data in databases may be even more difficult because these databases include data from very large numbers of samples with differing sources. When we have a new DNA sequence, we usually compare it with the huge collection of publicly available sequences to determine function. Each sequence in a database may have a different requirement for approval of access and benefit sharing if sequence data is included in international agreements. Recently, options for dealing with benefit sharing for digital sequence information (DSI) have been identified (Scholz et al., 2020), but none of these options may be easy to implement and satisfy all stakeholders. Disclosure of DNA sequence data is usually required as a condition of publication, but this may not be consistent with benefit sharing requirements.
Plant scientist need to have a voice in the policies and practices that are developed internationally. We urge pant scientist to become familiar with the issues in their country and internationally and contribute to the development of effective approaches at all levels. We need to be proactive in developing a code of practice for plant scientists that provides leadership to policy and law makers in governments globally.
Marden E (2018) International agreements may impact on genomic technologies. Nature Plants 4, 2-4.
Sherman B and Henry RJ (2020) The Nagoya Protocol and the problem of historical collections of plants. Nature Plants 6, 430–432.
Scholz, A H, et al. ( 2020) Finding Compromise on ABS & DSI in The CBD: Requirements & Policy Ideas from a Scientific Perspective.
About the authors
Ros Gleadow is a Professor in Biological Sciences at Monash University. She is a plant ecophysiologist with an interest in bioactive plant products and crop wild relatives. She is President of The Global Plant Council.
Brad Sherman is an ARC Laureate Fellow and Professor of Law at The University of Queensland where he researches on intellectual property and food security.
Robert Henry a Professor at QAAFI, a Research Institute of the University of Queensland. Current research targets plant genome sequencing for the capture of novel genetic resources.
You are receiving this email because you are an elected representative, contact or board member of one of the Global Plant Council’s Member Organizations.
Please share the content of this email with your contacts, members, and on your websites and newsletters!
You might also like
Durante cientos de millones de años, las plantas han tenido la capacidad de aprovechar el dióxido de carbono del aire utilizando energía solar. La red de investigación está en camino de
Estimada comunidad de la CSPB, Los organizadores de la Marcha por la Ciencia en Chile, le han solicitado al Consejo de Sociedades Científicas, representado por el Dr. Jorge Babul, su
Primer banco de semillas y laboratorio de germinación del SNASPE para rescatar y restaurar la flora nativa de la isla Robinson Crusoe
Con el fin de colectar, analizar y propagar las plantas endémicas y autóctonas de la Isla Robinson Crusoe, Conaf inauguró el primer banco de semillas y laboratorio de germinación. Este